The most Overrated/Underrated OP-Characters

[peleihno]

That's because there is no set power level for the individual captains. To reach the level of a Yonkou, a captain would need a strong crew and a lot of influence, thus you have nothing to factor strength on. Shanks may be stronger than Mihawk but you cant get that from Shanks being a Yonkou, when Mihawk excels in their fighting style.

Ok

What point am I missing?

I think I already said I'm not seriously arguing that titles decide the entirety of the Mihawk/Shanks debate. I never was. Seems that you think that I am, but I'm not. This is more an argument of which title is superior, I suppose.

@bolded: That Yonkou are the most powerful pirates, plain and simple. Yonkou means four kings/four emperors. It refers to the individual first and foremost. You say the title requires a powerful crew and allies to attain, but so does the title of PK and yet that is a testament to Roger's own power.